Quoted
Originally posted by parador
Have we violated against the Indochine protocol ? NO !
Quoted
Originally posted by Brockpaine
Yes, actually, China has violated the Indochina Protocol, and repeatedly. For years, China refused to negotiate with France over the disputed Paracels, citing that they'll wait for an independent Indochinese regime.
Quoted
Originally posted by Brockpaine
This position by China flies in opposition to Point 2.A of the Protocol, identifying France as the source of political and military authority in Indochina. Because China has refused to negotiate so many times in the past, the French feel 2.A has been ignored.
Quoted
Originally posted by Brockpaine
On at least two occasions, France has warned China and the rest of the signatories that China's actions are interpreted as violation of the Protocol, and yet China continued to ignore French offers for negotiation. Even after France offered an all-Indochinese negotiating team, China continued to refuse to negotiate with them. Despite China's repeated violation of their treaty commitments, France is still going forward with its commitments to the Protocol, and providing informational updates on Indochina to the Chinese and the rest of the other signatories - because unlike China, France made a commitment they intend to uphold.
The fact that China dismissed their claim to the Paracels in the recent statement does not mean everything is somehow fixed in regards to China's relationship with France or Indochina.
This post has been edited 1 times, last edit by "parador" (Oct 6th 2012, 12:13am)
This post has been edited 1 times, last edit by "TheCanadian" (Oct 6th 2012, 4:13am)
Quoted
Originally posted by parador
For China it looks like, if you didn't share the opinion of France , you are an evil and a warmonger.
This post has been edited 1 times, last edit by "BruceDuncan" (Oct 8th 2012, 1:42am)
This post has been edited 1 times, last edit by "Kaiser Kirk" (Oct 8th 2012, 8:47pm)
Quoted
Part 3: Conflict Resolution
A. In the event that the parties disagree on the interpretation of any clause in this contract, an arbitration panel shall be appointed to resolve the dispute. The panel shall consist of a representative from France or Indochina, a representative from one of the SATSUMA signatories, and a chairman to be selected by the French/Indochinese and SATSUMA representatives.
B. Decisions rendered by the arbitration panel shall be binding.
Quoted
Originally posted by Kaiser Kirk
However, much as the Filipino statement was rhetorical, so was mine. No one bothers to use them, I can't think of anyone who wants to be judge, but they existed, and it would make sense for the Dutch rep to point out that there's a mechanism to address the Filipino Rhetoric.
Quoted
Originally posted by TheCanadian
The American Reaction from Washington:
The United States government is deeply disappointed that the Government of China went and undertook this seemingly rash move. It is in the view of the United States that the rationale for the Chinese departure was poorly thought out, especially considering that they declare they were not given a seat as a Permanent Member yet did not formally petiton for one or make a proposal for a change to the Membership.
The United States government has therefore requested an audience with either the Chinese Emissary in Washington, or with senior members of the Chinese government so the Chinese government can give a full detailed explanation as to the real reason behind this move.
Quoted
Originally posted by Valles
The Kingdom of Nordmark regrets the departure of China from the League of Nations as a lessening of the brotherhood of mankind, but does not regard the agitation and alarm of its fellow league members as appropriate to the existing provocations.
Quoted
Originally posted by Valles
The Kingdom of Nordmark regrets the departure of China from the League of Nations as a lessening of the brotherhood of mankind, but does not regard the agitation and alarm of its fellow league members as appropriate to the existing provocations.
Forum Software: Burning Board® Lite 2.1.2 pl 1, developed by WoltLab® GmbH